I want to know…

[
[
[

]
]
]

November 16, 2026 · Knowledge Management Made Simple

Imagine reading 100 books about swimming.

You know everything about water, arms and legs.

“Wonderful!” says Pavel. “I’m an expert swimmer!”

Oxana smiles.

“Excellent. Have you ever been in a swimming pool?”

“Does the bathtub count?”

Researcher Roger Schank believed that meaningful learning often happens through experience, practical tasks and mistakes.

Let’s explore three funny examples.

1. Oxana’s Gardening Lesson

Pavel reads a book about growing tomatoes.

He memorises every chapter.

Then he plants his first tomato.

Unfortunately, he forgets to check the soil.

The plant begins to suffer.

“Your tomato looks disappointed,” says Oxana.

Together, they examine the soil and adjust the watering.

What did we learn?

Reading provides useful information. Practical experience helps us discover how to apply it.

2. The Museum Guide Disaster

Pavel memorises 50 facts about dinosaurs.

He becomes a museum guide.

A visitor asks:

“Why did dinosaurs disappear?”

Pavel freezes.

“That’s not question number seven!”

Oxana suggests practising with visitors’ questions instead of only memorising facts.

What did we learn?

Realistic situations help us practise using knowledge, not merely repeating information.

3. The Backup That Saved Nothing

Pavel creates a computer backup.

“Success! Everything is safe!”

Oxana asks:

“Have you tested restoring the files?”

“Why? The button was green!”

They test the backup.

The folder is empty.

“Congratulations,” says Oxana. “You’ve successfully saved nothing!”

What did we learn?

Testing a procedure reveals problems that instructions alone may not uncover.

The Big Idea

Schank emphasised learning through meaningful activities, goals, experiences, and reflection on mistakes.

Stories of previous experiences can also help us recognise and solve new problems.

Why This Matters for Knowledge Management

A good knowledge system should preserve practical lessons: what we tried, what happened, why it mattered and what worked.

What About Artificial Intelligence?

AI can create realistic simulations, explain mistakes and retrieve similar experiences.

But an explanation isn’t a substitute for testing skills in practice.

“All real learning involves learning by doing.”

Source: Roger C. Schank, Dynamic Memory Revisited, Chapter 10, “Learning by Doing,” Cambridge University Press, 1999, pp. 172–194.

The takeaway: Don’t just collect instructions. Practise, make mistakes and record what you learn.

Because a green backup button doesn’t guarantee that your files survived.

Leave a Reply